Supreme Court CEC Hearing: 10 Days to Reply on SIR
The Supreme Court gave petitioners ten days to file a rejoinder to the Election Commission affidavit on the SIR and did not scrap the roll revision or order a probe against the CEC.
Verdict: false alarm.
The roll revision that removed about 13 crore voters from the electoral rolls is being litigated at the top court, and the claims being made about what the bench decided are wrong.
Short answer: Neither thing happened. On Tuesday, October 27, 2026, a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, granted the petitioners ten days to file a rejoinder to the Election Commission’s counter-affidavit on the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, and listed all the connected matters for hearing on November 17, 2026. The bench did not strike down the SIR and did not order an SIT probe against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. It did something narrower and more consequential than either: it said it would “examine everything”.
1. What the bench actually did
The Indian Express live coverage of the hearing sets out the sequence. The Supreme Court granted the petitioners ten days to file a rejoinder to the Election Commission’s affidavit on the pleas questioning the functioning of CEC Gyanesh Kumar and the poll panel. On the previous date of hearing, the court had issued notice to the Election Commission of India, Gyanesh Kumar and the other two Election Commissioners.
The Hindu adds the part that turned into the viral claim. Senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, who appears for the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi, made what he called an “innocuous, non-invasive” request that the court either direct the Election Commission to preserve, or call for the filing of, the “complete records and decisions” concerning the SIR exercise. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta represented the Union government and senior advocate Maninder Singh appeared for the Election Commission, and both questioned the request.
The Chief Justice’s answer was the line that ran across every report of the hearing: “We are aware of everything; we will examine everything.” The court then posted all the matters for further hearing on November 17, which the Times Now and Moneycontrol reports also give as the next date.
What the court did not do is also on the record. The Hindustan Times reported that the Supreme Court refrained from directing the Election Commission to preserve its files, internal notings and communications. The Times of India reported the case as one where the Supreme Court deferred the hearing and granted the petitioner ten days to reply to the Commission’s counter-affidavit.
2. The three petitions
The Indian Express sets out what is before the bench. One petition, by social activist Rakesh Kumar Singh, refers to alleged differences between CEC Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, and argues that Article 324(1) of the Constitution “does not vest the superintendence, direction and control of elections in an individual Chief Election Commissioner. It vests those powers in a Commission.” The petitioner urged the court to declare the SIR, and all actions, decisions, directions and measures taken under it, invalid from the very beginning and without legal authority.
The second petition, by Delhi-based lawyer Shailendra Mani Tripathi, seeks a probe by an independent, high-powered judicial inquiry commission or an SIT headed by a retired judge of the top court.
The third is fresh. On the same day, the Supreme Court issued notice on a petition filed by Trinamool Congress leader and Rajya Sabha member Dola Sen, represented by senior advocate Menaka Guruswamy, against the functioning of the Election Commission and the alleged “tampering” of Form 6 during the SIR in Bihar. The Hindu reports her contention that the Election Commission issued a press note claiming the Supreme Court judgment in the Bihar SIR authorised the change to Form 6, and Guruswamy’s submission that the institution was “justifying the tampering of Form 6”.
The Hindu also reports the scale that the petitions are arguing about. The SIR has excluded approximately 13 crore voters from the electoral rolls.
3. What the Election Commission put in its affidavit
The Commission’s response was a united front, and its legal position was that the petitioners are asking a court to restrain a constitutional function.
The Indian Express reports that the affidavit, filed in response to the petition by Rakesh Kumar Singh, said it “has been approved for filing… by a unanimous decision of the three members of the Election Commission, i.e., two Election Commissioners and the Chief Election Commissioner.” The Commission said all decisions relating to the SIR were unanimously taken by the Commission, that SIR is legal and its process justified, and that the petitioners’ allegations relating to changes in voter registration procedures and decision-making are misconceived.
On Form 6, the Commission termed the contention that Form 6 was amended as “misleading”, and said only the Additional Declaration annexed to Form 6 was amended, “to introduce the concept ‘mapping’”. The Hindu reports the Commission’s position that the additional declaration is not part of the statutory Form 6, and that a CEC can be removed only in accordance with the procedure applicable to a Supreme Court judge.
The Hindu also notes the internal friction alleged in the petitions, with both Election Commissioners complaining about procedural irregularities, coupled with the unilateral and authoritarian conduct of the CEC during the SIR exercise. And it records the counterpoint from senior advocate Vikas Singh, appearing for the lead petitioner Rakesh Kumar Singh, who said the Commission’s affidavit “accepts many of the charges we are making.”
4. Why the viral version is wrong
The claim contains two separate assertions, and the record contradicts both.
The first is that the Supreme Court struck down the nationwide SIR. It did not. The matter stands for November 17, 2026, with ten days for a rejoinder. The SIR has been running, the roll revisions have been published, and the questions about the exercise are being litigated rather than decided.
The second is that the court ordered an immediate SIT probe against CEC Gyanesh Kumar. That was a prayer in one of the petitions, advanced by Shailendra Mani Tripathi’s lawyer. A prayer is not an order. What the bench did was take ten days to let the petitioners respond to the Commission’s affidavit.
The pattern behind the false version is worth naming, because it recurs. A direction sought in argument, an inquiry asked for by a lawyer, and a hearing that granted time are three different things, and a headline that fuses them into “court orders probe” is the product of that fusion rather than of reporting.
5. What is still open
On November 17, 2026, the bench takes up the batch. Three things sit unresolved and all three are consequential.
Whether the SIR and every act done under it can be declared void from the beginning for want of statutory and constitutional authority, as Rakesh Kumar Singh urges. Whether the Commission must preserve and produce its files and notings on how the roll revision was decided. And Dola Sen’s fresh plea on whether Form 6 was altered in the Bihar SIR without the court’s approval, which the Commission denies and the petitioners call documented in the Commission’s own press note.
The “examine everything” promise is not a judgment, but it is not nothing either. On a matter where the Government of India, the Election Commission and the Leader of the Opposition are all represented before the same bench, a court that says it will look at everything has not yet decided anything, and anyone telling you it has is reading the hearing instead of the order.
Sources to check yourself
- The Indian Express live updates, October 27: the ten-day grant, the bench composition, the Commission’s unanimous-decision line and the text of both petitioners’ arguments.
- The Hindu, October 27: Singhvi’s request, the Solicitor General’s objection, the “examine everything” remark and the 13 crore voter figure.
- The Times of India: the deferral and the ten-day grant to Rakesh Kumar Singh.
- Times Now: the 248-page counter-affidavit and the November 17 listing.
- Moneycontrol: the notice on Dola Sen’s Form 6 plea and the November 17 date.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Did the Supreme Court order an SIT probe against the Election Commissioner? A: No. The probe was sought by a petitioner. The court granted ten days for a rejoinder to the Commission’s affidavit and listed the matter for November 17, 2026.
Q: Did the court scrap the Special Intensive Revision? A: No. The SIR is not struck down. The petitions seeking to have it and every action taken under it declared void from the beginning are pending before a bench headed by CJI Surya Kant.
Q: What did the Chief Justice actually say? A: The Indian Express recorded him as saying “We are aware of everything; we will examine everything” before posting all the matters for further hearing on November 17.
Q: How many voters were removed by the roll revision? A: The Hindu reports the SIR has excluded approximately 13 crore voters from the electoral rolls, which is the scale the petitions are arguing over.
Reader discussion
Conversation for this story opens with memberships. Until then: found an error? Report it — we correct visibly.






